The Man Behind A Prairie Christmas: Stories are Jeff Gould’s way into our hearts.

by | Nov 22, 2025 | A Prairie Christmas, Interview, Jeff Gould

Story by John Andrews
South Dakota Magazine, July/August 2025

Opening Scene: The Recycling Plant Story

The article opens on Jeff Gould’s front porch in Sioux Falls. During a two-hour interview, he repeatedly says, “I’ll tell you a quick story.” That phrase defines him. Storytelling is not something he does — it’s who he is.

He shares a defining moment: speaking to workers at Millennium Recycling. The setting is loud, cold, industrial — cinder block walls, flickering fluorescent lights, machinery humming. The audience is small, hardened, distrustful. Many are formerly incarcerated. They are guarded, distant from each other.

Jeff begins with something universal: sledding. Snow. Childhood. Gradually, they lean in. The toughest man smiles. A woman laughs. The emotional temperature changes.

When he runs out of prepared stories, he improvises. He teaches them how to say “Merry Christmas” — look someone in the eye, shake their hand, mean it.

One by one, they do it.

Later, his friend explains: these men are fighting to survive. They’re tired of being judged. Jeff’s stories reminded them who they used to be.

That is the heartbeat of the article:
Stories reconnect people to themselves.

Jeff admits that even after telling that story countless times, it still moves him to tears. Christmas, he says, isn’t about nostalgia icons. It’s about love.


The Legacy of A Prairie Christmas

The show traces back to 1938, beginning with Ray Loftesness and Lofty’s Holiday Inn. Lofty blended personal stories from Garretson, World War II, and touring with Fred Waring’s band with traditional carols.

After Loftesness passed in 1991, the show continued as Christmas Memories. Twenty-one years ago, Jeff took over, renamed it A Prairie Christmas, and reshaped it through his own life experience.

The show airs weekdays from 1–3 p.m. on KELO Radio starting the day after Thanksgiving through Christmas Eve. It’s syndicated to other stations and now includes live theatrical productions. A new streaming channel called “I Like That Story” launches November 15 for on-demand listening.

The program has become seasonal ritual — background to baking cookies, wrapping presents, decorating trees.


Jeff’s Path: Radio, Detour, Calling

Originally from the Twin Cities, Jeff studied at the University of Minnesota and Brown Institute. His early radio career began in Mitchell, then southwest Minnesota, before moving to Sioux Falls in 1991.

He and his wife Libby — a longtime music teacher — moved an 1885 house to acreage south of Sioux Falls and raised four daughters.

At one point, he considered leaving for a bigger market. A colleague bluntly told him he wasn’t Rush Limbaugh or Howard Stern. That forced a surrender moment: he handed his career over to God.

The very next day, he was offered a job in radio sales.

That role sharpened his discipline and optimism.

Then a funeral home client asked him to join as a manager. He left radio and spent 15 years serving grieving families.

That season shaped him profoundly.

He began officiating funerals — eventually more than 600. Sitting with families, listening deeply, he discovered that in grief, stories surface clearly. He calls his work “planting seeds and pulling weeds.”

What was wise in this life? What was destructive? What endures?

Those services became laboratories for human truth. After each one, another story entered his collection.

Eventually, he wrote seven books, including Insight and Inspiration from the Heartland, structured around life’s four 25-year chapters.

Then came the call asking him to host the Christmas program.


The Craft of Story

Jeff says building the show is about taking people on a ride:

  • A funny story

  • A nostalgic story

  • A “mascara” story (he jokes that he ruins a lot of mascara)

He works from a thick binder of personal memories, listener submissions, and historical anecdotes — origins of candy canes, Slinkys, lawn darts.

He chooses stories based on the emotional weather of the day. If it’s snowing, he talks about snow. If he’s irritated, he selects something that steadies him.

He emphasizes radio’s intimacy. Without video, it feels like conversation, not performance.

“It’s just you and me,” he says.

Live shows add music, local performers, and visuals — including childhood photos and cultural relics like lawn darts (which he jokes were attempts to eliminate children of the 1950s).

He shares small, tender memories:

  • Playing Alvin and the Chipmunks records repeatedly.

  • His sister sewing their mother a striped pillowcase dress with large gold buttons.

  • His mother proudly wearing it, then protecting it from “ruin.”

The power lies in recognition. Listeners recall their own forgotten stories. He describes them as treasures in an attic — hidden but intact.

People thank him for helping them remember.


The Enduring Truth

The article closes by reminding readers that Christmas can become noise — shopping, events, busyness.

But for an hour, listeners can sit quietly and be reminded of love.


America’s Story (Sidebar)

After realizing that A Prairie Christmas loses demand after December 25, Jeff created America’s Story — a broader show using music, poetry, and historical narrative to explore eight traits Americans inherited from the founders.

He stresses that it is not political speech. It’s narrative — the remarkable story of American government.

The timing aligns with the nation’s 250th anniversary in 2026.